MetaChat REGISTER   ||   LOGIN   ||   IMAGES ARE OFF   ||   RECENT COMMENTS




artphoto by splunge
artphoto by TheophileEscargot
artphoto by Kronos_to_Earth
artphoto by ethylene

Home

About

Search

Archives

Mecha Wiki

Metachat Eye

Emcee

IRC Channels

IRC FAQ


 RSS


Comment Feed:

RSS

25 May 2010

Realigning Body Perception I had a flash of realization recently.[More:]Lots of my friends - as do I - have a cut off limit for weight.

You know the magic number that if you approach you panic and throw yourself into dieting and exercise?

My Mum and her 2 sisters were all very petite. For them that magic number was 8st. Yeah ye olde measurements (sorry UK). 2 of my cousins and I all ended up being much taller and more athletic - so I passed that 8st milestone when I was about 16. Which means I was a pretty average teenager.

8st = 50.8023 kg = 112lbs

I'm just shy of 170cms (5'6) tall.

For the first time I decided to calculate a rough BMI with those numbers. It would put a person my height quite under normal weight at a BMI of 17.5.

Dammit I've felt so much guilt about it for the last 20 years! I should have thought to check sooner - damn different measurements... 8st sounds so heavy to someone who deals in kgs.

I don't think they deliberately wanted to make us feel bad - but I suspect we became an extension of their own fears of becoming heavy. I think having a magic number is a good thing - but only if you make it a realistic one.

Now I feel like baking cookies...
Good for you for getting some peace of mind! You are beautiful. Forget about it.

I track my weight daily, it works for me - right now my BMI is hovering around 24. I am more comfortable in my skin when it is around 23. My waist to hip ratio is in the very good category. So as a bigger but normal sized woman, it helps me keep perspective, and get things in check if I notice scale creep on average over time.

I went to the gym the other day and the personal trainers are understandably struggling to drum up business in this economy. I got a sales pitch for a new program, and the peppy guy kept asking me what are my weight loss goals. I shrugged. Then he asked if I had weight loss goals. I said not really - maybe five pounds. He said "that's all? you don't think you can loose more than that? wouldn't you like to?" I just said I didn't have the cash and walked on. I wonder if he would have been unethical enough to sign me up if I said I wanted to loose 25 pounds - that'd still be a technically normal weight, but I've never weighed that in my adult life, and I'm over 40, when it's harder to loose.

I was ok at the time, but now it makes me a little mad.
posted by rainbaby 25 May | 13:47
Heh. My mother had a magic number as well, for her it was 9 stone, which as a 5'9" woman put her right around the same BMI as your mum, gomi. My mother has a very unhealthy body image though and I reacted against that by getting fat as a teenager. Now, I'm still a bit overweight - I think my BMI is around 26 - and I do want to lose some weight, but only 10-15 lb, because I know I feel good when I am around that weight.
posted by gaspode 25 May | 13:55
I feel like baking cookies

I'll take either.
posted by Firas 25 May | 14:02
I got my BMI down to, like, 24.9, which was good, then I had the cancer scare, in which weight loss was equated, in my mind, to a tumor growing inside me and I was terrified every time I got on the scale and I'd lost ANYTHING, and reassured when I gained.

So now I am heavier, and really need to get rational about it all and get my BMI down again.

Women do not have a corner on the body image neurosis market. . .
posted by danf 25 May | 14:36
Women do not have a corner on the body image neurosis market. . .

No but it often goes in the other direction. I spent the first 35 years of my life feeling self-conscious that I was too skinny even though I was in a healthy BMI range. Now in my middle age, I'm quite a bit overweight but feel far more comfortable even though I'm certainly less healthy now.
posted by octothorpe 25 May | 15:14
Actually my Mum was a lot shorter than me so for her 8st was still in healthy range.

I didn't rebel but I do remember being upset and crying over being "fat" as a teenager - although I was just normal.
posted by gomichild 25 May | 15:21
Actually my Mum was a lot shorter than me so for her 8st was still in healthy range.


Ah. My mother was one of the "I'm so fat" super-skinny people. She gave up smoking about 10 years ago, and is no longer super-skinny, although still a lot more slender than me. Which I hear about. A lot.
posted by gaspode 25 May | 15:47
Reverse issue: I used to have a BMI of 18.3 and looked like a skeleton. Which is not good when you're 6'6".
Now at middle age I have a BMI of 22.5 after doing some weightlifting. And I feel a bit more normal.

Did you know btw that Kurt Cobain used to wear multiple layers of clothes because he felt so skinny?
posted by jouke 25 May | 15:48
*hugs gaspode*

Us Mums gotta be careful about the body image perception we pass onto our kids.
posted by gomichild 25 May | 16:00
What?! Don't I get any hugs?!!
It's because I'm so bony, isn't it?!

I shouldn't post dronken
posted by jouke 25 May | 16:04
*puts on thick sweater, gives jouke hug*
posted by gomichild 25 May | 16:05
Aww.
The Friendly Skeleton hugs you back.
posted by jouke 25 May | 16:11
I was skinny, now I'm a bit tubby. I'm actually kind of enjoying it.
posted by jonmc 25 May | 18:52
It's a new users welcome thread! || We forgot our own birthday.

HOME  ||   REGISTER  ||   LOGIN