MetaChat is an informal place for MeFites to touch base and post, discuss and
chatter about topics that may not belong on MetaFilter. Questions? Check the FAQ. Please note: This is important.
21 May 2007
The Symptoms Worst. Simpsons. Parody. Ever. →[More:]A cringeworthy spoof from the now defunct Christian humor magazine GLAD. (WARNING: website might make you go blind.)
I think I just puked a little in my mouth. I read the title and I was going to make about how "the symptoms don't lie" but the site killed any chance of making that joke.
A Christian humor magazine? Maybe Mark Twain was right when he said there is no humor in heaven.
Ok, I'm going out on a ranty limb here, but that first page especially is just vile. There's something quite icky about it and not just in a trying-to-convert-you kind of way. It's just dripping with a most unwholesome and unchristian loathing -- almost a sense of sublimated hatred or violence. I think that's what fundamentalist-style religions do -- they force one to sublimate and repress everything that doesn't fit into their narrow framework and then it works it way out in really strange ways.
Okay, true confessions here -- I think the Simpsons as a show isn't all edgy and revolutionary, but is sort of a throwback with lots of traditional ideas. It vaguely irritates me. I think South Park is way more challenging to social norms.
The Simpsons has been part of our cultural landscape for almost two decades, with minimal change to characters or style over that time. It IS tradition. Besides, Matt Groening based the central family on his own family growing up in the 60s-70s and the look and pace owes much to animation that came before, unlike South Park, which pretty much invented its own look and sound. SP uses that almost-zero-dimensional look to be able to do the show the same week it's aired, allowing instant 'topicality', but what it parodies and ridicules for the most part are the non-establishment, the outliers, the 'weird individuals'. South Park is faux challenging. And the last 10 minutes of Sunday's 400th Simpsons episode bit the hand that feeds it (FOX and Big Media in general) harder than I ever remember seing on network TV. And I remember the Smothers Brothers.