MetaChat is an informal place for MeFites to touch base and post, discuss and
chatter about topics that may not belong on MetaFilter. Questions? Check the FAQ. Please note: This is important.
My first thought was that Scott Simon tried his hand at TV and it did not really *take* and I am glad that he's back where he belongs on Saturday Morning.
Also, don't have cable, not getting it so if this is a hit, I spose I'll rent the dvd's or depend on *ahem* the kindness of strangers.
My complaint about them doing a tv show, is that I like people to master and extend the range of their medium (as they've done in radio), to move on to another medium with a similar format always depresses me.
(For example, great comic book writers who are doing it just to try to break into tv or movies).
I haven't seen the show yet, but if the trailer is any guide, the radio show pace and edit philosophy is gonna cost 'em viewers. Tuning in halfway through a radio TAL story is often an exercise in futility, as they favor stories with a 15 or 20 minute development span, and even if they do an interest bridge, or foretell, they tend to be pretty coy about it. That's just not gonna play for big numbers in cable TV.
The show may find it's audience, but it won't get much of a new audience from channel surfers. Hence, as a former broadcaster, I predict a short and fondly remembered life for the TV show. I hope I'm wrong. I do like to see new TV work.
I agree. I first "saw" Ira Glass in the They Might Be Giants movie "Tale of Two Johns" and decided then and there I wanted to marry him. We unplugged our TV January 1 and it's been "TAL" podcasts that keep me sane during the day.