MetaChat is an informal place for MeFites to touch base and post, discuss and
chatter about topics that may not belong on MetaFilter. Questions? Check the FAQ. Please note: This is important.
23 January 2007
OMIGOD!!!!!! CROWDED HOUSE is reuniting! And they'll be playing here in SoCal in a few months at Coachella! I have just spent the past 20 minutes running around my house screaming.
Yep, Paul Hester committed suicide about 2 years ago. At the time, Neil Finn said there'd never be a reunion, but according to the article, he'd recently been recording his latest solo record with erstwhile CH member Nick Seymour, and apparently it just turned into... a Crowded House record. And now, with the 10-year anniversary release of Farewell to the World concert CD/DVD (I remember my ex and I actually fantasized about maxing out a credit card just to fly from Chicago to Sydney to see it!), it evidently feels right to say hello to the world once again.
God, I'm so happy! Never seeing Crowded House originally was always one of the top regrets of my life as a music fan.
I'm really looking forward to hearing the new Neil Finn solo album - his last two were great. I'm not a huge fan of Crowded House, but Together Alone is absolutely stunning. If, and it's a big if, they can top that, it'll be a great album.
Oh yeah, and RATM is interesting. I have a friend, who works for Audioslave's label in the UK, who's been saying for months that Audioslave have all but officially called it a day. Cornell has a solo album due out in March and the band are on "hiatus" whilst he tours that. And now RATM have reformed...
Uh, and James have reformed for a tour (although their Wikipedia page said they never actually split - they were just inactive. For a long time.). No mention of an album, though.
For me, RATM were one of those "2 or 3 great songs per album, and they were usually the singles" type bands.
box, come on. Is criticising RATM of limits? 'expressing yourself artistically' means that they can only be effusively praised? I'm merely stating the obvious: they're 'revolutionary' stance was nothing but posturing.
Nothing but posturing? Oh, I dunno--I'd guess that, just like with most people, they tried, not always successfully, to balance their political ideals with their other concerns--in this case, greed and the desire for fame, and to climb on the scenery at the MTV awards and release what is undoubtedly the worst version of 'Maggie's Farm' ever recorded.
Don't get me wrong--I'm pretty sure that I hate RAtM's brand of shout-along crap-rock a whole lot more than you do, and their politics are simpleminded even by dorm room bull session standards.
But critizing RAtM for their corporate-record-label hypocrisy is like shooting fish in a barrel. And, when it's so easy to find hypocrisy in pretty much any human being who has ever lived, I think that this kind of criticism isn't particularly constructive, and, worse, that it discourages people who might otherwise be tempted to try to do some good in this world.
I'm pretty sure that I hate RAtM's brand of shout-along crap-rock a whole lot more than you do, and their politics are simpleminded even by dorm room bull session standards.
Hey, I actually love shout-along rock, you should know that, but they suck by those standards, too. And their politics wouldn't bug me ever so much if they weren't so strident and the hypocrisy so blatant. And I think a healthy cynicism about people's motives, including our own, is simply maturity.
Please tell me you're kidding is kind of insulting.
I only said that since black8 and matteo generally have excellent (meaning similar-to-mine) taste in music. And it's got zero to do with cool, I could care less about cool. I'm probably the least politically astute person here and I could see through the who Che Guevara shtick.
Hey, I like RatM, Rush, and Dio. I wouldn't travel halfway across the country to see 'em, but I don't change the radio station when their songs come on. If liking high energy, meaningless pop is wrong, then I don't want to be right.
FUCK YOU I WONT DO WHAT YOU TELL ME (money, royalties)
FUCK YOU I WONT DO WHAT YOU TELL ME (radio play, big tour)
FUCK YOU I WONT DO WHAT YOU TELL ME (Audioslave's latest bit it)