MetaChat is an informal place for MeFites to touch base and post, discuss and
chatter about topics that may not belong on MetaFilter. Questions? Check the FAQ. Please note: This is important.
What gets me about all this fretting about the "unqualified" minorities who end up at these colleges is that the "good ole days" of which these fat cats bemoan the loss were, I think, the days when dull (i.e. unqualified) young men from "good" (i.e. rich/connected) families were essentially guaranteed spots in these schools.
So when they complain about unqualified students being admitted, they seem to be really complaining that THEIR type of unqualified student has been replaced by a DIFFERENT kind of unqualified student.
When, in fact, all indications seem to be that student bodies at elite schools have never been more qualified than they are today.
"the days when dull (i.e. unqualified) young men from "good" (i.e. rich/connected) families were essentially guaranteed spots in these schools" haven't ended, not by a long shot. I suspect that if any "unqualified" minorities are displacing "qualified" students, it's because the fat cats' own "unqualified" progeny are perfectly safe.
Having earned a Bachelor of Business in the 1970s (after changing majors from a Liberal-Arts-ish Communications), I never saw any "Liberal" bias in my college education. The Business professors (and most Econ professors) all had to pass a 'Milton Friedman School' litmus test even before Friedman was that well known. That's MY anecdotal experience.
A conservative I know was recently bloviating to me about a certain high-ranking school he had been considering for his daughter. He put it out of the running because, to paraphrase: half the students get in for diversity reasons and another quarter are Asians who obsess over test scores and have no social lives, so that means my daughter only has 1/4 of the student body to associate with.
I stumbled across a message board for would be investment bankers not too long ago ... I was googling something about my alma mater and this discussion came up.
Someone spouted off their theory that the "second tier" of elite universities are where all the "good students" are these days ... They are taking refuge in schools like Notre Dame, Georgetown, Bucknell, Vanderbilt, the "public ivies," etc., because all the undeserving diversity admits had crowded out these good, normal students from the first tier elite schools.