MetaChat is an informal place for MeFites to touch base and post, discuss and
chatter about topics that may not belong on MetaFilter. Questions? Check the FAQ. Please note: This is important.
12 November 2009
I'm gonna cry I don't 'get' McSweeney's Lists anymore→[More:]
I'm like sitting here thinking am I getting stupid or what? Check this out:
Yeah I got the gist of the Coolidge thing but if we were to uncompress those two relationship ones what's she saying? Like in a sentence, e.g. "men who say X are Y" or "when I said X I meant Y" or whtaever.
McSweeney's is occasionally funny. But most of the time, it reminds me of people who give off strained, fake laughs at public events -- not because remark X by the speaker was objectively that funny, but because laughing shows that you are in on the joke, and therefore cool.
Yes, I'll agree with you that McSweeney's is awfully precious and tries to hard, but about 10% of the time I see something there that is so damn funny that it makes me keep coming back. Although I used to check in daily, now I just go there every few weeks and rifle through looking for the gems. Often the gag isn't very funny, but the rhythm of the words is almost poetic, which I kind of like.
But yeah maybe it's an age thing. It's like, 'alright, you read Thomas Hobbes and you want to relate him to your hangover. I get it. I'm done reading Hobbes. I'm done with binge drinking. What else is up.' (in fact, one of their 'some reasons we might reject your submission' explicitly states: "Your submission concerned life in college.")
Now and then I'll go on a McSweeney's binge and enjoy clicking and giggling out loud for half an hour or so. The rest of the time I just sort of roll my eyes at it.