MetaChat REGISTER   ||   LOGIN   ||   IMAGES ARE OFF   ||   RECENT COMMENTS




artphoto by splunge
artphoto by TheophileEscargot
artphoto by Kronos_to_Earth
artphoto by ethylene

Home

About

Search

Archives

Mecha Wiki

Metachat Eye

Emcee

IRC Channels

IRC FAQ


 RSS


Comment Feed:

RSS

15 December 2008

Missing the point or hitting it on the head? Another discussion about a questionable ad....[More:]

On my bus this morning, there was a public service ad that showed a picture of an attractive college-aged girl wearing a relatively tight T-shirt. The shirt read

DO ME
a favor and speak up
when you hear
sexist comments


I know what they're trying to say and all. (It was some campus group, I think.) But was that really the best way to say it? Attention getting, sure, but won't it invite the kinds of jokes they're trying to draw attention to?

What say ye people?
It probably will, but those are the kind of people that probably wouldn't be influenced by an ad against sexist comments in the first place.

(Then again, I'm all about tasteless t-shirts.
I got bitched at on a fashion comm I'm in on LJ for wearing a t-shirt that said on the front "1 in 4 people suffer from mental illness" and on the back "Check 3 of your friends. If they're okay, it's YOU!" It was from the Psych Club at Lyco. I also have a "Homophobia is so gay" shirt from the LBGT club at Lyco too. There's also a "fuck anger management" shirt with a gun on it and a "school shootings tour" shirt in my drawer somewhere. I'm not allowed to wear those at home anymore.)
posted by sperose 15 December | 12:52
That kind of thing always makes me think the people behind the ad were move interested in a cool idea (OH! So arch and ironic!) than asking if it is really an effective idea.
posted by arse_hat 15 December | 13:15
What arse said.
posted by Miko 15 December | 13:19
I wish you had a picture of that ad. It encompasses exactly why thou shalt not do puns or try to be clever in advertising. You just end up making shit.
posted by dabitch 15 December | 13:34
That is good advice, dabitch.
posted by Miko 15 December | 13:57
Yeah. Along with what everyone else already said... Putting a lot of small text to read on a woman's chest is not actually going to promote the desired behavior.
posted by It's Raining Florence Henderson 15 December | 13:58
T-shirts? Everyone knows that the real solution to all of society's ills is more songs by Sting.
posted by jonmc 15 December | 13:59
nobody listens to me though, Miko.

nevermind me, I'm having a shit life
posted by dabitch 15 December | 14:05
Reminded me of this other ad campaign that kind of subverted itself: this one, meant to be against statutory rape/pedophilia, but kind of off the mark in photoshopping little girls onto sexy adult female bodies.
posted by Miko 15 December | 14:13
I am very ambivalent. I think that it might plant a seed somewhere, which is good. The targeted audience would likely have a hostile reaction, but anything that can push the needle, however slightly, in the direction away from sexism and objectification are a good thing.

(I wonder if there has been anyone who, upon reading that ad, mused, aloud, "nice tits.")
posted by danf 15 December | 14:32
not only all of the above comments, but the tag line itself is too long for a solid impact statement.
posted by Lipstick Thespian 15 December | 19:28
Those adverts are disturbing, Miko. And I don't think it's in the way that they intend.
posted by jonathanstrange 15 December | 19:40
I had to get reading glasses recently, so I'd probably either not notice the fine print or have to get extra close to read it. It also seems pretty presumptuous to wear a shirt that implies the wearer is, um, worth doing.

Poster [PDF] of a T-shirt with the phrase, from the Campus, Education, Awareness, Support, and Effect (CEASE) program at SUNY Fredonia. The fine print's actually not that small.

They also have a similar shirt [PDF] that says:

I WANT ACTION
When it comes to preventing violence against women.
posted by kirkaracha 17 December | 14:04
something new to me in human relations || I just came across Jill Santopietro

HOME  ||   REGISTER  ||   LOGIN