MetaChat REGISTER   ||   LOGIN   ||   IMAGES ARE OFF   ||   RECENT COMMENTS




artphoto by splunge
artphoto by TheophileEscargot
artphoto by Kronos_to_Earth
artphoto by ethylene

Home

About

Search

Archives

Mecha Wiki

Metachat Eye

Emcee

IRC Channels

IRC FAQ


 RSS


Comment Feed:

RSS

11 February 2008

Back to defending the indefensible. [More:]Among most critics and people who consider themselves serious rock aficionados, the genre of 1970's hard rock is considered a barren wasteland. AS most of you know, I disagree, I think it's like any other genre, there's good stuff and bad stuff.

Today I'm going to talk about two bands that are probably the most critically despised of that era. First, Grand Funk Railroad. Barely remembered now, these guys were huge throughout the 1970's, racking up platinum albums one after the other and even joining the select group of rockers to sell out Shea Stadium.

Never the deepest band in the world, they spcialized in loud, riffy, punchy crowd-pleasers-'Foot Stompin' Music' in a word, with the occasional break for some bloozy emoting. Not exactly deep, like I said, but in a barroom or after a tiring day with a cold beer, it definitely has it's sweaty, luggy charm and drummer Don Brewer had one of the great whiteboy afros of all-time. It was also Brewer who provided Grand Funk with their one undeniably transcendent moment. One night on tour they got into an argument with tourmates HUmble Pie about the merits of British versus American rock to which a boozy Brewer declared 'We're An American Band', then woke up hungover and wrote the song of his career (tightened up nicely by Todd Rundgren's production). The song is the blueprint for all the Anthem Rock to come, so whether you love it or loathe it, give the progenitors their due.

Now, on to Black Oak Arkansas. Derided as a cut-rate Skynyrd back in the day, they still managed to rack up some hits. Most notable was the beautifully over-the-top 'Lord Have Mercy On My Soul' with vocalist Jim Dandy Mangrums ponderous mumbled philosophy and a catchy-as-hell chorus adding up to a stoner rock classic. Then there's their cover of LaVern Baker's 'Jim Dandy To The Rescue' (latter-day video, but backup-vocalist Ruby Starr still looks great) with is a rousingly charming mess.

Both these bands are still slogging it out today which says something, and their influence shows up in surprising places: look at the work of Raging Slab and the Supersuckers, or in the case of the whol genre, check out the comp Sucking the '70's.

Was this stuff revelatory or 'important?' Probably not. Fun and influential? Hell yes.
In resaerching this post I found out that Ruby Starr is no longer with us. RIP.
posted by jonmc 11 February | 10:00
*tries desperately to favorite this post click-click-clicketiclick* Nice!
posted by dabitch 11 February | 10:24
I remember watching Black Oak Arkansas on "In Concert". That guy certainly had a distinctive voice. "We're An American Band" was one of the first 45's I ever bought before I graduated to LPs.

Those bands are still around? I don't know whether to be happy or sad for them. Hope they're doing it just for the fun of it.
posted by DarkForest 11 February | 10:27
I adore Grand Funk Railroad. My brother had their albums and I just loved them.

At one time Mark Farnon (have I got that name right?) was singing Christian music, but that was about 10-12 years ago.

posted by JanetLand 11 February | 10:32
Hope they're doing it just for the fun of it.

Probably that and to make a living. People got to eat and if you can make a living playing music, even at state fairs and the like, why not?

At my corner bar, I usually go in the early weekday afternoons, when the patrons are mainly guys in their late 40's who worked for the city so they could retire at 48 and hang out in bars all day. Putting on 'Heartbreaker' or 'Mean Mistreater,' usually gets me a thumbs up and a 'I saw dese guys at the gawden back inna day!'
posted by jonmc 11 February | 10:32
At one time Mark Farnon (have I got that name right?) was singing Christian music, but that was about 10-12 years ago.

Farner. Yeah, he was doing the Christian rock thing (although still sounding like Grand Funk apparently). he had some substance abuse problems apparently.

I remember a scathing piece by Ira Robbins calling GFR 'The Band That Killed Rock and Roll'. He makes some points, but I still think he's being unfair.
posted by jonmc 11 February | 10:36
Derail: I had a science teacher in jr. high who would periodically and completely out of the blue stop mid-lesson and ask, "Whatever happened to Grand Funk Railroad? God, I LOVED that band! Does anyone know what happened to them?"

She was fun. If we wanted to get out of taking a quiz or listening to that day's lecture, all we had to do was either ask about GFR or say, "Hey, Mrs. Teacher--is it true that you went to Woodstock?"
posted by jrossi4r 11 February | 10:42
Here's a link to the full article that jon mentions.
posted by box 11 February | 10:49
thanks box. I usually like Ira Robbins, and I get the point he's trying to make, but I think he's being too hard on GFR. and comparing them to the Stooges is like comparing the Flintstones to R. Crumb-two totally different things.
posted by jonmc 11 February | 10:55
Barely remembered now...

Nobody knows the band Grand Funk? The wild, shirtless lyrics of Mark Farner? The bong-rattling bass of Mel Shocker? The Competent drum work of Don Brewer?

For more on Grand Funk, consult your school library!
posted by Atom Eyes 11 February | 11:29
Ha! Nice one, atom eyes.

and for the record, I'm not positing all these 'indefensible' bands as lost autuers, merely saying that just about all of these old '70's warhorses (not just GFR and BOA, but say Uriah Heep, Humble Pie, Rainbow etc) all had at least a few moments of genuine inspiration to their credit.
posted by jonmc 11 February | 11:35
and positing this kind of music as directly antagonistic to punk rock is silly. I point you to this conversation between Michael Azzerad and Chuck Klosterman:

Azzerad:Obviously the kid at the Black Flag show is a bit of an independent investigative thinker. He or she probably had to read about Black Flag in a fanzine...can look past the glossy production and see the gist of a band. That takes a certain independence of thought. Someone who makes their way to a Black Flag concert in 1981 is obviously different then the kind of kid whos at Van Halen because the Van Halen kid reads only mainstream publications...But that's not a value judgement aboout them as a human being.


Way to pat yourself on the back there, Mike.

Klosterman:Wrong. That is a value judgement. What it says is that the kid who likes Black Flag is a better music fan than the kid who likes Van Halen. And that's ridiculous. It's possible these two kids like Black Flag and Van Halen for diametrically differrent reasons, but it's just as possible they like them for the exact same reason ("Man, these guys fucking rock!")

Thank you, chuck.
posted by jonmc 11 February | 11:43
I HATEHATEHATE "We're an American Band." I don't hate GFR per se-and it's true, they were a very big deal when I was a teenager-but that song, I despise.

posted by bunnyfire 11 February | 15:46
So, what do you think of Creedence Clearwater Revival?
posted by bunnyfire 11 February | 15:47
I love them. 'It Came out Of The Sky' and 'Run Through The Jungle' are both in my 300, remember?
posted by jonmc 11 February | 17:34
I just want to drop in here and state that GFR did an amazing cover of the Rolling Stones' "Gimme Shelter".

That is all.
posted by chillmost 12 February | 05:36
20 questions with Robyn Hitchcock. || Winter Blahs - Who's with me?

HOME  ||   REGISTER  ||   LOGIN