MetaChat is an informal place for MeFites to touch base and post, discuss and
chatter about topics that may not belong on MetaFilter. Questions? Check the FAQ. Please note: This is important.
This has always seemed like the definitive "Don't do it" response to me, which is why I've always avoided MuFi. It'd be interesting to play around with it if you could incorporate samples or if mash-ups were kosher, but I'd assumed (perhaps incorrectly) that they were not.
So, since I don't want to piss on cornflakes over there... I thought mash-ups and sampling were strictly verboten on MuFi.
It's not encouraged. I talked to Manitoba a little about that one, because I figure Music can (like the rest of Mefi) usually handle the occasional transgression from the norms for something pretty cool, and that one was pretty cool.
Sampling, covers—both a little touchy, though barring that direct reply from Matt that you link, he tends to be pretty chill and Ah What The Heck on stuff that isn't crazy visible or getting out of hand. I wouldn't really be cool with a big rash of mashups on Music, but that one by it's lonesome isn't really hurting anyone.
Anyway, it's my understanding that "hey, complaint/etc re: Metafilter" is kinda frowned upon on Metachat, so I'd say let's nix this here so as not to cause headaches for the mecha mods. togdon, If you want to try and get an answer, you might consider emailing Matt or starting a thread in the grey.