MetaChat is an informal place for MeFites to touch base and post, discuss and
chatter about topics that may not belong on MetaFilter. Questions? Check the FAQ. Please note: This is important.
i'd love to get in on his discussion about personality disorders, but publicly is such a crapshoot.
i bet patients haunt this guy's blog like a desecrated buriall ground.
i have got to stop reading this. i have too many things i want to say about the bpd vs npd thing and it's interesting about too any issues i wanna say something about.
But this is an interesting note about elderly suicide rates.
I've just read basically the whole blog. I like a lot of it. His criticisms of psychiatry, in the service of improved care for patients, echo many of my own. I like his attitude. I'll be thinking more about the stuff I read there before I make any larger evaluations of it.
In my experience (see, there's my disclaimer) psychiatrist-parents go wrong in a very specific way. They judge behavior, not the person. It sounds like a good thing, I know. For kids, it's a disaster.
The psychiatrists with children-patients handle their kids in the same way. They teach them what they are allowed to do and what they are not, what is acceptable and what is not-- but make no judgment on the kids themselves. This is a disaster, because doing this denies the kid's identity, which is the whole purpose of childhood to begin with. Rules then exist in an invented framework, or worse, in a vacuum. There's no internalization of the rules; there's no superego. Just some arbitrary limits on id.