MetaChat REGISTER   ||   LOGIN   ||   IMAGES ARE OFF   ||   RECENT COMMENTS




artphoto by splunge
artphoto by TheophileEscargot
artphoto by Kronos_to_Earth
artphoto by ethylene

Home

About

Search

Archives

Mecha Wiki

Metachat Eye

Emcee

IRC Channels

IRC FAQ


 RSS


Comment Feed:

RSS

19 January 2006

Ask MeCha - music downloading I'm sure this has been asked and answered before, but I'm asking now, okay?[More:]So, the wife and I have grown weary of not being able to immediately download any song that strikes our fancy, and we have finally admitted to ourselves (and the rest of the IP world) that we are ready to pony up and start paying for the "privilege". However, we are leery of some of the things we've heard about download services, and want to know what both what we'd be getting into, and what we'd be getting out of it.

Our requirements are few, but exacting:

1. We want to be able to have at our beck and call recent popular songs (example: today, she asked me "have you heard that song by Death Cab For Cutie? I kind of like that") as well as odd-ball things that strike our fancy (example(s): we frequently listen to a cappella and world music college radio, and often hear something that we would like a copy of).

2. We want MP3s. That's the format we know, and we don't want to have to deal with any others.

3. We want to pay a fair price for a song, but after we do, we want to be able to have the file for our very own, and to burn it onto as many discs or copy it to as many different devices (always for our own listening pleasure, of course) as we desire.

By way of contrast, we don't want to pay an outlandish monthly fee for a service from which we can download a set number of songs per month from a tiny catalogue, and which we can only listen to on a specific computer, on a specific day of the week.

Please, good people - what are our options, and your recommendations?
Hmm. And I foolishly posted a lengthy, open-ended question (which will undoubtedly need some feedback to be adequately narrowed and discussed) late at night and perilously close to my own bedtime. Any respondents should therefore please be assured that I will read and reply appropriately in the morning.

Thanks again, in advance!
posted by yhbc 19 January | 23:56
Emusic and Audio Lunchbox are the two services that I use. Fuck iTunes. Both distribute MP3 files without any DRM nonsense to deal with. There's a monthly fee with a set number of songs in emusic's case, but it's reasonable and you actually download the files, not rent them like a lot of other places. Neither have much major label pop music, but in both cases you can browse their catalog and sample the selection before committing to anything.
posted by cmonkey 20 January | 00:02
Yeah, I'll second emusic. I can't always find everything I want there, but there's lotsa goodness within.
posted by bmarkey 20 January | 02:19
iTunes rules if you're a Mac/ipod user. They have popular stuff and some strange obscure stuff. If you don't want it with DRM, burn it to CD as an audio file then re-rip it from CD to any format you want (i.e. mp3). Best of luck and have fun with it.
posted by alteredcarbon 20 January | 03:19
I signed up to eMusic for a few months and found that the catalogue was not enough to my liking to be worth the monthly fee. That said, it was by far the best of the several that I tried.

While I love iTunes dearly, I have never forgiven it for telling me that I could not peruse its lovely offerings because the country I reside in is unacceptable. I have never visited the iTunes music store for this reason, even though I am now (I think) welcomed with open arms. I'm shallow that way.
posted by dg 20 January | 04:57


I've found AudioLunchBox to be great - I've found some really amazing, obscure stuff there, and it's all non-DRM and reasonably priced. For your desire to have popular songs at your beck-and-call, well I don't know how much I can help you with that. [cough]allofmp3.com[/cough]
posted by Jimbob 20 January | 05:06
I have subscriptions to both eMusic and Rhapsody, and while I love eMusic, dg is right that the catalogue is somewhat limited. (It is, however, a great way to explore non-mainstream music, and I've kept the subscription for that reason.)

Rhapsody I've been very happy with, and you might want to avail yourself of their free trial dealie. They do limit to five the number of computers on which you can play downloaded songs; you can also burn them to CD (and then, I assume, re-rip, as alteredcarbon mentions). Their catalogue seems quite extensive to me. They've also recently gone public with a beta version of a web-based service (instead of making you use their proprietary player), which means that with a subscription you can stream and listen to anything they offer on any computer.
posted by kat allison 20 January | 08:21
There's the Russian services which are cheap. I've used one, but their selection is spotty although their range of formats is high (including FLAC), it made me nervous to give them my credit card number, and the whole thing is shady anyway as they're exploiting a loophole in the Russian licensing words. (In other words, I don't think this is helping the actual artists.)
posted by kmellis 20 January | 09:44
z-i-b-e-t-g-e-o-e-t-g-e-i-o-e-g || thursday night mayfly radio

HOME  ||   REGISTER  ||   LOGIN