MetaChat is an informal place for MeFites to touch base and post, discuss and
chatter about topics that may not belong on MetaFilter. Questions? Check the FAQ. Please note: This is important.
06 November 2005
Willy Wonka's Father is Count Dooku!1! I'm a little slow, but I saw the stupid film last night.
I do not, kenko. The stupid backstory? Making Wonka a wimpering lonely child instead of a badass, wacked-out candy inventor? Leaving out the part where Charlie fucks up? The total soppiness that is utterly opposed to the tone Dahl is loved for, despite greater narrative fidelity? The appalling travesty of the music? (Again, I *like* Danny Elfman, and I hated it.)
I respectfully disagree with dame. I thought the movie was great, though of course different from the book and the previous movie. Dahl is equally parts sappy (ever read Danny, Champion Of The World?) and dark, which I thought the movie communicated well.
i liked it a lot, but i think depp's awesome portrayal of wonka made the movie; otherwise it would have been kind of weak. i really enjoyed the visual effects though...
Well, that's the best kind. Okay, it's second to the kind where you first disagree and then realize I was right.
Dahl is equally parts sappy (ever read Danny, Champion Of The World?)
Yeah, every time I began Danny, I fell asleep. Though I did enjoy all the others I read (a lot of them). I guess it is that the type of sweetness rang false.
i think depp's awesome portrayal of wonka made the movie. . . . i really enjoyed the visual effects though...
I liked both but thought they weren't enough. I also left the utterly flat and straight out dull portrayals of all the other kids. It was like they were terrorists or something: they are evil because they are evil.
To be fair, the other version of the film is one of my faves. I tried really hard to like this one, but it didn't work. Oh well. Thanks for letting me get this out.