MetaChat REGISTER   ||   LOGIN   ||   IMAGES ARE OFF   ||   RECENT COMMENTS




artphoto by splunge
artphoto by TheophileEscargot
artphoto by Kronos_to_Earth
artphoto by ethylene

Home

About

Search

Archives

Mecha Wiki

Metachat Eye

Emcee

IRC Channels

IRC FAQ


 RSS


Comment Feed:

RSS

04 November 2005

Help me get a clue with audio stuff. Or don't.[More:]So I'm listening to some German lieder on my PC, which I've noticed really make poor audio quality apparent.

Whenever the vocalist sings extra high or extra loud, I'm getting distortion. It doesn't seem to be a problem with the audio file quality.. it's a 207 kbps mp3 (encoded with: Unknown).

So I'm guessing it's my speakers or my soundcard. Is there any way to tell which, if I don't have any higher quality equipment around to compare with?
Stick some headphones in, and see if you get the same distortion. If you do, it's your soundcard.
posted by brainwidth 04 November | 13:25
I should have done that anyway. Yeah, the distortion is still there. Do you agree that 207 kbps mp3 should be high enough quality to avoid this kind of thing?

So the sound card! all along..

posted by agropyron 04 November | 13:42
It could still be the mp3, even at a high bit rate. You're experiencing a phenomenon known as "clipping," which tends cause the sound to distort or cut out at high volumes and pitches. You can get rid of at least some of the clipping by reducing the volume of the files with MP3Gain.
posted by brainwidth 04 November | 14:34
Was it recorded live? If so, the problem may be on the recording end. Otherwise, yeah, cut the gain.
posted by klangklangston 04 November | 16:17
ditto it likely being a problem with recording. if it's clipping with headphones your ears would probably be bleeding (assuming you normally don't need to have the volume turned way up).

if you have a program that will plot out the waveform (no idea what) you should be able to identify the loud bits (biggest wiggles - this is a technical term). if the tops of the biggest wiggles are all cut off flat (another technical term) then the problem is in the recording.
posted by andrew cooke 04 November | 16:46
hmm. although high notes even at low volume is kind of odd. i don't have an explanation for that if you really hear it through speakers and headphones.
posted by andrew cooke 04 November | 16:49
Hmmm. I have noticed it on a variety of my music, but my mp3s are a mixed bag, and I probably have a lot of cruddy ones in any case.

I'm going to try the AV-710 sound card. It's only $23.
posted by agropyron 04 November | 17:07
I've been meaning to upgrade my sound card anyhow, and I'll be interested to see if I notice any difference in general.
posted by agropyron 04 November | 17:08
I can't recommend the Turtle Beach Riveria enough. I lucked out when I got that at Fry's for 29.99. Full duplex real 6-channel audio (5.1), with a nearly pro-level signal to noise ratio. (96-98 dB or something like that.) The channels are fully assignable for doing things like quadraphonic sound, or dolby or STS surround, or multi-channel audio applications like recording while playing back, etc. It also has an optical output for use with pro audio toys or home theaters or the like.

If other MP3s don't do what you're talking about consistantly, it's probably that particular MP3.
posted by loquacious 04 November | 21:08
IT IS FRIDAY! || Pitman. is. everywhere.

HOME  ||   REGISTER  ||   LOGIN