MetaChat REGISTER   ||   LOGIN   ||   IMAGES ARE OFF   ||   RECENT COMMENTS




artphoto by splunge
artphoto by TheophileEscargot
artphoto by Kronos_to_Earth
artphoto by ethylene

Home

About

Search

Archives

Mecha Wiki

Metachat Eye

Emcee

IRC Channels

IRC FAQ


 RSS


Comment Feed:

RSS

25 September 2005

Ask MeCha: What is "the Divide" in Willa Cather's O Pioneers and On the Divide?[More:]I had always assumed it was The Great Divde. However, if you look closely at the map or, alternatively, read the description, the Great Divide does not run through Nebraska.

Even if you take into account that the setting of the book was likely before the time the Nebraska Territory was admitted into the Union, the last time Nebraska actually contained any portion of the Great Divide, it's clear from the later years in O Pioneers that the setting is always in Nebraska.

Does she mean "Where the West Begins", as in the 100th Meridian or previous state slogan? Or am I just overcomplicating the matter?
I think she's referring superficially to a generic divide, not specifically the continental divide. A divide is geographically any ridge or raised area that is separate from the rest of the landscape; Cather may have been using this to talk about both the location and psychology of her characters. They came from a European life to one completely different in Nebraska and had to adapt to that new way of life. Possibly she was using the title as a reference for both. Possible I am also overcomplicating. :-)

posted by DeepFriedTwinkies 25 September | 23:13
Possibly she was using the title as a reference for both.

Is it common for authors to use a proper noun, i.e. "the Divide", to refer to two or more separate ideas together? If so, does this technique or device have a name or other examples I can look at?

Thanks for the wisdom, DeepFriedTwinkies. Honestly, I don't think either one of us are being complicated enough. ;-)
posted by sequential 25 September | 23:21
Watershed divides exist in addition to the continental divide. I am along the Rock River, which flows south into the Mississippi and the Gulf, but a little bit east of here the streams flow east to Lake Michigan and out the St. Lawrence Seaway. Getting across this divide was a challenge for early explorers using these waterways, so they were quite aware of where they were.

There is a watershed divide between the Missouri river and the Arkansas river, which runs through south Nebraska. It is this which gave its name to the "Nebraska Divide" and Divide, Nebraska. In this map the "Republican", "Little Blue" and "Big Blue" watersheds flow south, not into the Platte.

Is it common for authors to use a proper noun, i.e. "the Divide", to refer to two or more separate ideas together? If so, does this technique or device have a name or other examples I can look at?

The term you're looking for is "metaphor" ... honestly, only pedestrian authors have one level of metaphor in mind when they're writing. Complex, intellectual authors like Nabokov or Kobo Abe have intricate metaphorical structures that can mystify, confuse, illuminate, surprise and startle you years after first reading them. Granted, Cather is not that complex, but I think DFT is basically correct in his assessment, and I can think of at least three major ways in which the "divide" is evoked by the situation.
posted by stilicho 26 September | 23:41
HomeworkFilter: || Ask MetaChat: Do you use Flash on a Mac?

HOME  ||   REGISTER  ||   LOGIN