MetaChat REGISTER   ||   LOGIN   ||   IMAGES ARE OFF   ||   RECENT COMMENTS




artphoto by splunge
artphoto by TheophileEscargot
artphoto by Kronos_to_Earth
artphoto by ethylene

Home

About

Search

Archives

Mecha Wiki

Metachat Eye

Emcee

IRC Channels

IRC FAQ


 RSS


Comment Feed:

RSS

11 February 2008

Ruh-Roh! Artificial sweeteners may encourage weight gain. [More:]

At least Saccharin. At least in rats. But the theory regarding the effect (coupled with evidence that artificial sweeteners are linked with obesity) seems to indict all artificial sweeteners.

Of course research is constantly indicating that X may cause Y, and I don't know about you, but I mostly end up filtering out most of this kind of thing (Eggs Bad! Oh, wait, No! Eggs good! Coffee Bad! Oops, No! Coffee Good! blah, blah, blah, tralala) - but this theory strikes me as damn logical. I think.

At least it seems to make sense that our bodies gear up for certain reactions based on initial signals such as those from taste receptors. Anyway, I don't use sweetener except in my coffee and tea (only because I'm not a soda fan), and I'm going to cut it out; I never felt good about using it anyway.
Oh, I'd also like to add the bleeding obvious: anyone using artificial sweetener on the advice of your doctor should clearly not jump the gun in making any changes. Talk to the doc.
posted by taz 11 February | 05:30
SUGAR RULES! Oh, and honey is yummy.
posted by dabitch 11 February | 06:05
Oh and that "gearing up" thing you speak of is also why you shouldn't serve sweet drinks (Juice/Soda) with food (or foods with sugar in it, think ketchup or stupid spaghetti sauces with HFCS in it) as the body gets the "yummy" signal and you will eat more, have seconds etc. Drink water with dinner and the "I'm full now, thanks" signal will hit the brain in time for you to stop eating. Good thing to know when you have kids with huge appetites. Let them eat all they want just limit the sweet drinks so that it really only is all they need to eat. (Perle regularly eats 8 fishballs in one sitting, which is really impressive at her age!)
posted by dabitch 11 February | 06:10


Sorry I messed up and didn't close tag. Did not show in preview.
posted by dabitch 11 February | 06:15
Not only is that an adult sized meal, I'm an adult and I really, really want it right now now.

I'm not sure about the don't-have-something-sweet with dinn-dinn thing, though - from this article, it seems like it tells the body, "METABOLIZE POWER - UP!" (in the case of natural sweeteners) ... which may actually maybe make sense of that feeling that people have for something sweet after dinner. (??!)

But this doesn't mean I think you are wrong. To me, it feels terribly wrong to have a sweet drink with a meal because the taste thing seems totally fucked up. Like, I don't want to take a bite of chocolate cake and fish at the same time, I don't want chicken and vanilla at the same time, and I don't want a sweet drink and my main food at the same time. Breakfast slightly excluded; I can have a sweet juice, or sweetened coffee with breakfast, and I seem to really crave some level of sweetness in the morning (- I've found if I have a spoonful of honey in the morning, I'm good to go, whatever).

So, I feel exactly as you do, but this report doesn't necessarily seem proof of this instinct in us.
posted by taz 11 February | 06:49
I usually drink sparkling water, both at home and when I go out. On my first visit to NYC last June, not realising that it's called seltzer, I wasn't sure how to order sparkling water at the bar, and, not wanting to look like a n00b, I had Diet Coke instead.

I had two large-ish Diet Cokes during the evening and a couple of hours later I felt really, really nauseous. I remember in the Odessa diner I thought I might throw up over gaspode (omg!). I put it down to jetlag and rich food, but ...

... on my last visit to NY a few weeks ago, I got sick again, terribly nauseous, after drinking a couple of cans of Diet Coke. I stayed off it after that and was fine.

Aspartame is poison, I tell you, poison.
posted by essexjan 11 February | 07:37
"No, no diet soda for me thanks; I'm on a diet."
posted by JanetLand 11 February | 08:27
Aspartame is poison, I tell you, poison.


I can't stand the stuff. So yes, taste poison!

I drink sparkling water with dinner (or plain ol' moo juice) for exactly that taste thing Taz talks about. Moo juice only goes well with some foods - like those fishballs! Mmmm.. Okay now I'm gonna make fishballs for lunch, Taz come on over.
posted by dabitch 11 February | 08:32
Remember Cher's Equal commercials back in the early 90's? 'You care more about what you put in your car than what you put in your body...' Well, I never put silicone in my car, lady.
posted by jonmc 11 February | 08:48
Hehe, yeah I keep thinking that when Britt Ekland speaks about recycling on Swedish telly. Where you gonna recycle your siliconed self, sugar? See what I did there? Sugar! Get it? Yes I know that was terrible
posted by dabitch 11 February | 09:05
I'm not quite on the "Aspartame is poison!!!!" hysteria bandwagon (Marion Nestle handles this rather well in her recent book), but there are more than enough reasons to drop the diet soda from one's intake. I recently did so myself and wish I had done sooner.
posted by mykescipark 11 February | 09:11
I don't drink dieat soda either. I drink regular soda, usually Mountain Dew or Root Beer. Other than that it's usually beer, coffee, or Strawberry Quik.
posted by jonmc 11 February | 09:15
I'm an everything in moderation kind of person. I probably have one can of diet soda every couple of days, and I'm comfortable with that.

(most of the time at home when I want something sweet I drink ginger/lemon tea sweetened with honey. YUM.)
posted by gaspode 11 February | 09:15
I don't generally drink diet soda; I don't like the taste (Diet Coke is the only one I can drink and not taste in my mouth for hours afterward).
posted by ThePinkSuperhero 11 February | 11:04
Fresca, TPS. Delish.
posted by gaspode 11 February | 11:16
Fresca and vodka is a fantastic summer drink. MMMMmmm... summer.
posted by BoringPostcards 11 February | 11:18
I'm a HUGE sparkling water fan, and now when Ramlösa and Loka comes in a whole bunch of flavors I'm in heaven. (I only drink Ramlösa and Loka & Perrier when I canfind it because those are well known springs, not bottled bubbly tap water. Man that's such a rip-off.)

Youknow what else is a fantastic summer drunk? Vodka, (1 shot) crushed ice and a three finger thick layer of thinly sliced cucumber in a glass. I'm serious.
posted by dabitch 11 February | 11:21
I'm Bunny, and I am a Diet Coke fiend.
posted by bunnyfire 11 February | 15:49
I drink diet coke with my rum. Other than that, it's usually diet green tea. I just can't bring myself to "waste" calories on non-diet beverages and I, oddly enough, really hate drinking water.
posted by jrossi4r 11 February | 15:58
I love the taste of Fresca, gaspode, but it has one of the worst aftertastes, IMO. Which is sad, because I like the taste of it so much.
posted by ThePinkSuperhero 11 February | 16:08
I don't drink diet soda. But I don't drink a lot of soda anyway, and, when I do, I usually go for either the organic stuff or the Mexican stuff. Pure cane sugar. I don't even like HFCS, let alone artificial sweeteners.
posted by box 11 February | 16:21
TAB KILLS
posted by dhartung 11 February | 17:18
Ehhnnnhhh! Blind cat and blind puppy love each other! || Pond surface duck bathed in a halo of angelic light is watching you masturbate

HOME  ||   REGISTER  ||   LOGIN